The best possible answer you can get when you ask which pie everyone wants on Thanksgiving: “A sliver of everything, please!” The dessert spread is the most fun part of the meal, and the more pie options you have, the better! You’ll probably want to cover all the classics, so you’ll need an apple pie and a pumpkin pie, plus a pecan pie if you have nut lovers in the house. But if you want to branch out and add some other options, you’ll find dozens below. Ree’s beloved French silk pie is a holiday favorite in the Drummond house; it gets just as much attention as her aptly named I Love This Apple Pie. (Ladd is partial to chocolate pie; he says he could eat a slice every day.) Browse through this fun menu of holiday pies to pick out a few for this year’s feast. You’ll find fruit pies, pecan pies, pumpkin pies, chocolate pies, and cream pies, all organized by category so you can plan a good mix. Plus, you can choose from five basic crust recipes, including an easy press-in version (no rolling pin required!). Don’t worry, the recipes are all easy—choosing which ones to make is the hard part!

Pie Crust 101 title with decorative border elements
Decorative sign displaying the text "Fruit Pies" on a burgundy background with a checked border.
Pecan Pies sign with a maroon background and decorative border.


Pumpkin and sweet potato pies title graphic with a maroon background and white text.
Chocolate Pies sign with white text on a maroon background and a light-checkered border.
Custard and Cream Pies sign with a maroon background and white text on a checkered border.