Halloween wouldn't be nearly as fun without a glowing jack-o'-lantern sitting on the front porch. But as it turns out, plenty of other fruits and vegetables are just waiting for a transformation of their own.

Some varieties, like oranges and bell peppers, make adorable mini jack-o'-lanterns that are perfect for kids or decorating the dinner table. Others, like pineapples and watermelons, are unexpected porch décor that will have trick-or-treaters doing a double take. And if you're a fan of Halloween history, carving a turnip is actually a nod to the very first jack-o'-lanterns, long before pumpkins took over the spotlight.

Whether you're looking for a last-minute Halloween craft, just using what's already in your kitchen, or simply want your spooky porch display to stand out from everyone else's, these creative pumpkin alternatives are every bit as enchanting. So, grab your carving tools and get ready to give these unexpected fruits and veggies a frightfully fun new look.

carved halloween green jack olantern alternative halloween pumpkin as a watermelon and pineapple against rusty wall with space for text summerween time
Black Lollipop//Getty Images

Turnips

Long before pumpkins became the Halloween icon, people were carving turnips. According to Irish folklore, spooky faces were carved into hollowed-out turnips to ward off wandering spirits during Samhain, the ancient Celtic festival that inspired Halloween. They may be smaller and a bit tougher to carve than pumpkins, but they're a fun way to bring a little history to your decorations.

Bell Peppers

Orange bell peppers are the obvious choice, but red, yellow, and even green peppers work just as well. Their natural ridges already resemble miniature pumpkins, so all you have to do is carve a face into the side and remove the seeds. Jack-o’-lantern stuffed peppers are the perfect dinner to fuel a night of trick-or-treating!

healthy halloween food vegetables and dip in jack o lantern bell peppers close up against rustic wood
jenifoto//Getty Images

Watermelons

If you're celebrating Halloween in a place where it still feels like summer, watermelon makes a surprisingly great substitute. The thick rind is sturdy enough for carving, and the bright red fruit inside can be scooped out for snacking while you work. Best of all, you can serve the watermelon cubes right out of your carved creation at a Halloween party.

Oranges

Hello, mini jack-o’-lanterns! These might be the cutest Halloween decorations you'll ever see. Carefully scoop out the fruit, then carve tiny faces into the peel. They're quick, kid-friendly, and double as festive place settings for a Halloween dinner. You can even fill the hollowed oranges with candy or dessert after the holiday.

jack olanterns made from two tangerines
Olga Donchuk//Getty Images

Pineapples

Who says Halloween can't get a little tropical? A pineapple's textured exterior already looks eye-catching, and its leafy crown gives it an instantly playful personality. Carve a silly grin or spooky face into the sides, then place an LED tea light inside for a glowing lantern that's equal parts festive and unexpected.

Squash

Winter squash comes in all kinds of shapes, sizes, and colors, making it easy to create a one-of-a-kind jack-o'-lantern collection. Butternut squash creates tall, skinny faces, while acorn squash has a charming, storybook feel. Even decorative gourds can be carved with simple expressions for a porch display that's full of fall charm.

zenithal image with carved scary pumpkin, leaves and small pumpkins, antique wooden background, festive and autumnal tone
Corazza//Getty Images

Potatoes

They may not be the first thing that comes to mind, but large russet potatoes are surprisingly fun to carve. Their rough skin gives them a rustic look, and their small size makes them perfect for creating miniature jack-o'-lantern villages. Line several up along your windowsill or scatter them down the center of your Halloween table.

Pears

A pear’s unique shape makes it especially fun for creating quirky little characters. Choose a firm one that's not quite ripe so it's easier to work with and keep the designs simple. Pears are best suited for a Halloween table or party display rather than an all-night porch decoration.

two carved pumpkins and a pear with funny faces on a tree trunk in a garden, celebrating halloween
Mariia Vitkovska//Getty Images

Onions

Small but mighty, sweet onions have just enough room to carve tiny faces, making them ideal for tabletop displays or decorating a Halloween charcuterie board. Their papery outer skin also gives them an aged, ghostly look that's perfect for the season. Just don't be surprised if carving brings a few tears!

Apples

An apple a day keeps the boring Halloween decorations away! Firm, large apples are great for carving, especially if you're looking to make a few tiny jack-o'-lanterns for your Halloween table. Choose red, green, or golden apples for a whole little orchard of colorful characters. Since apples can brown once they're cut, they're best carved shortly before your party or Halloween festivities.

Headshot of Macie Reynolds
Macie Reynolds
Assistant Editor

Macie Reynolds is the assistant editor of E-Commerce and SEO for The Pioneer Woman.