Ree Drummond loves sugar cookies. In fact, her “all-time favorite, nostalgic, comfort-food, fun-to-make, low-fuss, non-snobby, yummy Christmas cookie of all time” is a sugar cookie recipe from her mom, Gee. She also has an unadorned soft sugar cookie recipe that is just as tasty when she’s not in the mood to decorate.
Either way, both recipes are easy to make and absolutely deserve a spot on your Christmas cookie platter. (The difference is that the soft sugar cookie recipe will spread in the oven because of the higher butter ratio, while the cut-out sugar cookies will not.) If you follow Ree’s instructions, they both yield a soft cookie center with crispy edges, which is exactly what you want.
But have you ever made another sugar cookie recipe and wondered, “Why are my sugar cookies hard?” Instead of a nice soft bite, they are rock hard and practically inedible. Such a bummer! It may be the recipe itself, or you may have made a few common sugar cookie mistakes. Here’s what to look out for and how to try to fix hard sugar cookies.
Common Causes of Hard Sugar Cookies
First, you want to make sure you have a tested recipe from the start to set yourself up for success. Thankfully, you now have several sugar cookie recipes from The Pioneer Woman to choose from. Next, avoid making these common mistakes.
Overbaking the Cookies
This is probably the most common reason your cookies are hard. It’s easy to overbake cookies, so take this cue from Ree: “Once the cookies start to look golden, pull them out. They'll continue to set up on the baking sheet as they cool.” Once sugar cookies start to brown, they're likely overbaked and will harden.
Adding Too Much Flour
Too much flour can result in a dense, dry, and hard cookie. The most accurate way to measure flour is by weight on a scale (in ounces or grams). However, most American baking recipes are measured by volume in cups, and converting can be a pain. Don’t worry! You can still be accurate when using volume measurements.
If you simply put your measuring cup in a container of flour, it will be compacted, and you will inadvertently scoop up too much. So here’s what you do instead: dip and sweep. First, stir the flour in its container to loosen it. Then dip your measuring cup into the fluffed flour, then sweep off the excess with a straight edge (the back of a butter knife works great!)
You can also spoon and sweep. Once again, stir and fluff the flour first. Then spoon the flour into your measuring cup and level it off by sweeping off the excess with a straight edge. Either way, it’s actually better to overfill the cup a little and level it off. If you underfill it, then you’re not being accurate either.
Overworking the Dough
If you overwork the dough, the flour will develop too much gluten, which results in tough cookies. The first way is by overmixing the dough once the flour has been added. You will most likely see this in the instructions when adding the flour: “until just combined.” Essentially, once almost all of the flour is absorbed, stop mixing. You can do a final few passes with your spatula to make sure everything is combined.
The second way you can overwork the dough is when you’re rolling it out. Don’t add too much flour on your work surface: a little goes a long way. Then, after you roll out and cut your dough, you can absolutely combine and roll out your scraps. Just know that the more times you roll out the scraps, the tougher the dough will be. Usually one round of scraps is best.
Storing the Cookies Incorrectly
Leaving cookies uncovered allows air to dry them out. After they cool or as soon as the decorations dry, store them in an airtight container. They should last about three days or so, depending on the recipe.
How to Fix Hard Cookies
If you accidentally made hard cookies, you can try to fix them! The best way is to add them to an airtight container with a piece of sandwich bread or even a brown sugar keeper overnight. By the next morning, the cookies should absorb the moisture and soften. This is actually how you can keep most cookie recipes soft!
If that trick doesn’t work, try a quick 15-second burst in the microwave (though you’ll have to eat the cookies immediately after). And if that doesn’t help, well, you might have to start over. Luckily, this list of sugar cookie mistakes and Ree’s recipes will help you get the soft consistency you’re looking for. Happy baking!














