There's a lot to love about Thanksgiving dinner, but homemade pies might just be the sweetest part of the whole day! After all, once the turkey has been carved and the mashed potatoes have disappeared, there's still one very important decision to make: Which one gets the first slice? Ree Drummond likes to get a jump on holiday baking by preparing her go-to pie crust ahead of time as part of her Thanksgiving cooking timeline. It freezes beautifully, but an all-butter crust, cookie crust, or store-bought dough works, too.
As for the fillings, there's something for every sweet tooth! Go with classic fall favorites like pumpkin, apple, sweet potato, or Ree's famous pecan pie, or shake things up with a maple syrup pie and cinnamon roll apple pie. On this list, you’ll even find slab pies for feeding a crowd and pretty pie crust designs for extra holiday flair. Whether you're a pie-baking pro or need a few crust-making tips, these recipes are worth saving room for!
1
Pumpkin Chiffon Pie
C.W. Newell
This chiffon version has all the warm, cozy spices of traditional pumpkin pie, but with a lighter, almost mousse-like filling. The secret is folding airy meringue into the pumpkin mixture, then piling it into a flaky pie crust.
This pie is basically a taste of fall wrapped up in a flaky crust. The sweet maple filling bakes into a rich, buttery custard that's wonderfully smooth and salted whipped cream takes every slice over the top. Think of it as a way to put that bottle of maple syrup to good use!
Who says cranberry sauce has to stay in its bowl? This no-bake pie turns the tart holiday favorite into a dreamy dessert. Best of all, there's no oven time required, so it's a handy make-ahead treat.
Apple pie is always a good idea, but this big-batch version makes sharing even sweeter. Instead of fussing with a traditional round pie, this slab pie bakes up in a sheet pan with a buttery, flaky crust and a generous layer of tender cinnamon-spiced apples.
Chocohlics will want to save room for this one: It brings together a fluffy, mousse-like filling and a crunchy chocolate cookie crust in one dessert. Still need convincing? Ree calls it “pure happiness in a pie shell!”
Apple pie is the Thanksgiving standard, but pears are just as tasty and seasonal. This dessert still includes a cinnamon-spiced, fruity middle, yet the crunchy streusel topping with almonds, cinnamon, and candied ginger will take it to a whole new level.
Looking for an easy Thanksgiving pie that you can make ahead of time? Try turtle pie. It’s made with pecans, but they’re used sparingly, which is perfect for those who prefer a more subtle crunch.
Turn everyone’s favorite childhood treat into a Thanksgiving pie! The moist chocolate filling is brimming with chocolate chips and chunks of golden walnuts (or pecans for a holiday-inspired twist!) that tastes just like a decadent brownie.
Imagine a classic pumpkin pie made in a sheet pan instead of a smaller pie pan. That's so even more guests can enjoy it—and come back for seconds. At the end, just cut it into squares and serve with whipped cream.
Two favorite fall flavors come together to make this scrumptious pie! It has a filling consisting of both cranberries and apples, along with some seasonal spices. A brown sugar, oats, and cinnamon crumble tops it off.
Just the thought of this delicious dessert is making our mouths water! Plus, it only takes six ingredients to bake. Sweet and tart Granny Smith apples are covered in sugar, pie spice, and flour, then sandwiched between canned cinnamon rolls. It's even frizzled with cinnamon roll glaze!
Silky smooth and loaded with spices, this pie recipe is a classic Thanksgiving dessert for a reason. We make things easy by cooking the sweet potatoes in the microwave before making the filling!
Do you say pee-can or puh-kahn? Who cares! The important thing is that you make this pie. 😂 It's everything you love about the fan-favorite treat: A gooey sweet filling with toasty pecans inside a golden crust.
This seasonal pie combines the topping of a buttery crumble with the flakiness of a pie crust. It's the best of both worlds! Serve it warm with hard sauce, whipped cream, or ice cream. Yum!
You can't go wrong with this classic holiday pie. It's a pumpkin lover's paradise! You can serve it as is or give it a special finish by adding the butter-pecan whipped cream topping.
The sweet, comforting, custard-like filling in this pie isn't anything fancy, but it's just darn delicious! We like the addition of lemon juice and lemon zest to give it a hint of brightness!
If you're planning a Southern Thanksgiving menu, chess pie should be on the top of your list. It's a classic custard pie with a cornmeal crust and a crispy caramelized layer on top.